That remark falls loosely into the category of ‘if I had a pound for every time that was said to me I would be a millionaire!’ Apart from the sheer impossibility of living with your nose in a book (just imagine the number of things you would walk into!) you know exactly what the remark means. It seems to suggest that reading is a slightly subversive activity and that exposing yourself to the wide world of learning and experience contained in books is somehow a distraction from what people like to call the ‘real’ world. I am sure that I read somewhere that Thomas Merton the Trappist monk and writer wrote of his entry into the Gethsemani monastery in Kentucky as a flight from the world that eventually saw him embracing the world through his writings, particularly his prodigious correspondence. I have looked at my reading in the same way- wherever I have gone in my reading, to distant planets, Middle Earth, Discworld or some historical period, the journey has always brought me back into the real world with some new insight or understanding. And the critics of reading are, in part, exactly right, this is a subversive activity because reading challenges you to look at the world (and worlds) in a different way.
This is even true of writers like Agatha Christie and Ngaio Marsh who manage effortlessly to provide readable ‘light’ fiction that can also be read as an examination of the times they lived in. I once rashly criticised Agatha Christie in conversation with my wife who challenged me to at least read one of her books (‘The Secret of Chimneys’), I read it and was so hooked I had to stay up until I had finished it- the reader is always learning!! Reading brings me comfort, challenge and surprise, for example, when the film versions of ‘The Lord of the Rings’ came out I was convinced that I would never be able to read the books again without seeing Peter Jackson’s interpretation and Alan Lee’s designs but I read the trilogy again recently and was amazed at how fresh Tolkien’s original vision remained, and, ironically, how ‘comfortable’ Middle Earth remained. Truly the world teems with stories and thankfully we are light years away from that place where some stories were privileged over others in the way that history was always written by the winners.
Reading can be seen as a solo activity, although the growth of reading clubs illustrates the fact that reading with others can be an exciting prospect. It is also perhaps a long way down the list of practical things that can be done to make the world a better place, but it strikes me that if more of us were found with our noses in a book the world and its inhabitants might be better understood and tolerance might grow and flourish. As long, that is, as we remember to look where we are going!
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band- just a record, more and less.